• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Alliance for Hope International

(0)Login
Login

Escape

Social iconSocial iconSocial icon

    • About Us
      • Our Team
      • Our Board
      • HOPE Rising Award
      • Lifetime Achievement Award
      • Join Our Mailing List
      • Annual Reports
      • Conference Hope Survey Reports
    • Our History
    • Training
      • Conferences and Events
      • HOPE Hub
      • Privacy Policy
      • Online Resource Library
    • Programs
    • News and Media
    • Shop Now
    • Donate
      • Check us out on Guidestar
      • Supporters
      • Conference Supporters
    • Contact Us

    • Blog
    • News & Media
    • HOPE Hub
    • CFJCN
    • SHOP Now
    • Donate
    • AFHI

    Racism, Implicit Biases Negatively Impact Credibility of Domestic Violence Survivors

    November 6, 2020

    Story By: Tuozhi Lorna Zhen

    The results of a new report on racial equity and biases in New York state courts are alarming, writes Tuozhi Lorna Zhen, a supervising attorney in the Domestic Violence Law Unit at NYLAG. She examines how racism and other implicit biases have a negative impact on domestic violence survivors being found credible in the state’s legal system.

    The results of a report issued Oct. 15 that examined racial bias in New York courts were devastating, but they were also unfortunately unsurprising. The Report from the Special Adviser on Equal Justice in the New York State Courts found that courts are “under-resourced, over-burdened,” and have a “dehumanizing effect” on litigants, of which the majority are people of color.

    Systemic racism is a stain in the fabric of our country’s history and its effects have a negative impact on those who rely on our legal system for justice.

    This is especially true in New York City Family Court, where I navigate being an Asian woman that represents survivors of domestic violence who are predominantly women of color. Many also experience poverty. My clients survived unimaginable horrors and bravely chose to engage with our legal system as a means to achieve safety from an abusive relationship.

    But there are compelling reasons why a survivor may not want to engage with our legal system.

    My colleagues at New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG), where I am a supervising attorney in the Domestic Violence Law Unit, and I often see that when clients of color report abuse to law enforcement—or engage with the legal system—they are more likely to risk being charged themselves (or mutually arrested with their abuser). They often feel unsafe or may be unwilling to report to police or our courts because communities of color have historically been overpoliced and overcriminalized.

    Credibility Questioned

    They are also less likely to be believed when they do come forward. A reportpublished by Georgetown Law’s Center on Poverty and Inequality found that “adults view Black girls as less innocent…than their white peers.”

    Racist and implicit biases by judges, police officers, and other players in our legal system, impact credibility determinations, as well as the level of sympathy we have seen historically given to victims of color versus white victims.

    Take, for example, a Black client of mine named Veronica (named changed for safety), who suffered years of physical and sexual abuse at the hands of her children’s father. Finally, after speaking to domestic violence counselors, Veronica sought an order of protection from the court against her ex-partner.

    During the trial, the judge questioned her credibility because she never called the police to report any of the incidents and chose to remain in her home despite her ex-partner continuing to harass her in her neighborhood even after their separation.

    My client attempted to explain that as a Black woman, she was distrustful of the police, and that she was also scared of what the police may do to her ex-partner, who was also Black. She also tried to explain that as a single mother with young children, choosing to remain in her home, which was close to family that could provide child care, was more important than moving to a new neighborhood that while safe, had no family support.

    The judge, ignoring the systemic racial and economic stressors that impacted Veronica’s decisions, found her not credible.

    Important Changes Needed

    Our system needs to change and it needs to change now. The report on New York’s courts has some important recommendations we need to dig into. But, I’d add that it’s time to rethink how our legal system assesses credibility when working with survivors of color.

    As part of NYLAG’s #RethinkCredibility campaign, we’re advocating that:

    1. Law enforcement, judiciary, and court personnel on all levels must complete implicit bias trainings.
    2. Complimentary to the report, we need better diversity in the judiciary and the attorneys appearing before them to reflect the population the county serves.
    3. A system must be established through which survivors can report bias and prejudice in the court system through a transparent process accountable to community stakeholders.

    These changes can transform the legal system to better help survivors of all backgrounds, but especially survivors of color for whom justice has for too long been elusive.

    This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of The Bureau of National Affairs, Inc. or its owner

    Write for Us: Author Guidelines

    Author Information

    Tuozhi Lorna Zhen is a supervising attorney in the Domestic Violence Law Unit at New York Legal Assistance Group (NYLAG).

    Click here for the original story. 

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Primary Sidebar

    Top Articles

    • Strangulation in sex can increase risk of stroke and brain injuries, distressing study finds
    • read more »
    • Strangled Victims Need Imaging
    • read more »
    • What Parents Need to Know About the Choking Game
    • read more »
    • Choking someone is often prelude to future homicide
    • read more »
    • Strangulation and Domestic Violence Murders
    • read more »

    Join Us Now & stay informed

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    our programs

    Nfjca Logo 2018 1
    Trainingiinstitute
    Cha Logo V12.28.18 2
    Justice
    Voices

    Logo Footer 501 W. Broadway, Ste A #625, San Diego, CA 92101 (888) 511-3522 | 1110 Hemphill St. Fort Worth, TX 76104
    © 2022 Alliance for HOPE International. All Rights Reserved. Design by TinyFrog Technologies.

    Login

    Lost Your Password?
    Register
    Don't have an account? Register one!
    Register an Account

    Registration confirmation will be emailed to you.