• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Alliance for Hope International

(0)Login
Login

Escape

Social iconSocial iconSocial icon

    • About Us
      • Our Team
      • Our Board
      • HOPE Rising Award
      • Lifetime Achievement Award
      • Join Our Mailing List
      • Annual Reports
      • Conference Hope Survey Reports
    • Our History
    • Training
      • Conferences and Events
      • HOPE Hub
      • Privacy Policy
      • Online Resource Library
    • Programs
    • News and Media
    • Shop Now
    • Donate
      • Check us out on Guidestar
      • Supporters
      • Conference Supporters
    • Contact Us

    • Blog
    • News & Media
    • HOPE Hub
    • CFJCN
    • SHOP Now
    • Donate
    • AFHI

    Landmark ruling deems employer liable for an employee killed by her partner while working from home

    June 2, 2020

    By: Madeline Hislop
    A recent court ruling has deemed an employer liable for an employee who was killed by her partner while working from home in NSW. The circumstances of the case are unique but given the proliferation of employees working from home the issue of employee safety when working from home is relevant.
    According to Cooper Grace Ward Lawyers, the landmark ruling involved concurrent interpersonal issues between people who worked closely together, were in a relationship and raising children together.
    Michel Carroll was killed by her de facto partner Steven Hill while working from their family home in NSW. Carroll and her partner were employed as financial advisors by a family company, S L Hill & Associates Pty Ltd.
    Steven Hill was charged with the murder of Carroll but was not found guilty on the grounds of mental illness.
    Carroll’s workplace was inside the family home and her employment was deemed by the NSW Court of Appeal to be a substantial contributing factor to her being killed.
    Carroll had two dependent children, a teenage son and a newborn baby, who made claims for death benefits under the Workers’ Compensation Act 1987 (NSW).
    The company had been deregistered, so the Worker’s Compensation Nominal Insurer responded to and then denied the claims.
    The Worker’s Compensation Commission determined Carroll died as a result of an injury arising in the course of her employment and payments were ordered for her children.
    The Nominal Insurer appealed against this determination, claiming there was no causal link between her employment and death.
    The Court of Appeal found that Carroll’s death occurred in the course of her employment, arose out of her employment and that her employment was a substantial contributing factor to her being killed.
    According to Cooper Grace Ward Lawyers, the evidence showed that Carroll was on-call from about 7.30am at home, her bedroom contained work files, she worked throughout the house and was expected to answer phone calls. She was performing employment related duties or on-call at the time she was killed.
    Her de facto partner had paranoid delusions that related to the way Carroll performed her work duties at home. The evidence demonstrated a direct connection between his delusions, Carroll’s employment, and that she was killed by him.
    Carroll’s employment was deemed a predominant cause of her death and Carroll’s children were paid $450,000 in death benefits.
    This tragic case of domestic and family violence highlights that employers must consider much more than simple ergonomics when they have employees working from home.
    “Usually there will be significant difficulty proving a causal connection between an injury caused by domestic violence and employment,” Cooper Grace Ward lawyer Shelby Wells said. “However, this case demonstrates the novel situations that can arise when workers are allowed to work in an environment where the employer has less control.”
    To view the original post, click here…

    Reader Interactions

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    Primary Sidebar

    Top Articles

    • Strangulation in sex can increase risk of stroke and brain injuries, distressing study finds
    • read more »
    • Strangled Victims Need Imaging
    • read more »
    • What Parents Need to Know About the Choking Game
    • read more »
    • Choking someone is often prelude to future homicide
    • read more »
    • Strangulation and Domestic Violence Murders
    • read more »

    Join Us Now & stay informed

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    our programs

    Nfjca Logo 2018 1
    Trainingiinstitute
    Cha Logo V12.28.18 2
    Justice
    Voices

    Logo Footer 501 W. Broadway, Ste A #625, San Diego, CA 92101 (888) 511-3522 | 1110 Hemphill St. Fort Worth, TX 76104
    © 2022 Alliance for HOPE International. All Rights Reserved. Design by TinyFrog Technologies.

    Login

    Lost Your Password?
    Register
    Don't have an account? Register one!
    Register an Account

    Registration confirmation will be emailed to you.